If you enjoyed the Keepers documentary series and want more of the same, check out these spooky documentaries.
The popularity of crime docu-series is skyrocketing right now. Netflix’s 2017 crime documentary The Keepers is still a hot topic. The unsolved murder of a Baltimore nun leads to revelations about widespread corruption in the Catholic Church. Each episode of The Keepers covers a different aspect of the case, including what happens behind closed (church) doors and who killed Sister Catherine Cesnik and what secrets she left behind in her body.
Crime documentaries, on the other hand, are not all created equal. True crime documentaries on everything from unsolved murders to terrifying urban legends will satisfy your morbid curiosity. Before you press play on these engrossing documentaries, make sure your doors are locked. You’ll get a glimpse into the truly evil minds that are behind some of history’s most horrific crimes.
On the 18th of February 2021, Scoot Allan updated this page: Fans of murder mysteries like the hit docuseries The Keepers, which is still one of the best and most mysterious in the last decade, will find plenty of new and exciting true crime content on Netflix and other streaming services. There are a number of other mysteries and shocking documentaries that have captured viewers in the same way as the captivating Boston mystery of the murdered nun, which we will explore even further with a few more creepy documentary recommendations while true crime fans are still discussing the case from The Keepers.
15. Deliver Us From Evil (2006)
Deliver Us From Evil, a 2006 film that also looked into child molestation and possible involvement with the Catholic Church in its central mystery, focused on The Keepers, which was about an unsolved Boston nun murder.
There’s an award-winning documentary by Amy J. Berg about the life and crimes of Catholic priest Oliver O’Grady, who was interviewed in Ireland after confessing to numerous counts of rape and molestation during his time in the church and whose knowledge of the crimes was also investigated.
14. The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann (2019)
When Madeleine McCann vanished from her hotel room in Portugal while on vacation with her family in 2009, it sparked a media frenzy and a nationwide search.
Madeleine was never found, and the mystery remains unsolved despite the miniseries’ efforts to put together a timeline and identify potential suspects. For true crime fans, this chilling documentary is a must-see due to the mystery surrounding the disappearance of the young girl from her seemingly safe hotel apartment just meters away from her parents.
13. Who Killed Little Gregory? (2019)
In 2019, Who Killed Little Gregory?, a French docuseries that investigates the 1984 death of youngGrégory Villemin, is sure to entice fans of The Keepers. It’s captivating, creepy, and mysterious.
While the tragic unsolved death of the child is the main focus, the book also examines the family’s experience of harassment before the child was kidnapped and drowned.
The media frenzy that followed the discovery of the child’s body and the revelation that the enigmatic harasser/potential murderer was only known as “Le Corbeau”/”The Raven” is also included.) is discussed.
12. The Staircase (2004-2018)
As the trials surrounding author Michael Peterson and his possible role in the mysterious death of his wife Kathleen, who was found dead at the bottom of a staircase in their home, continued, Jean-Xavier de Lestrade first released The Staircase in 2004.
It was a simple accident at first, but it quickly turned into a case full of twists and turns that dated back years to another mysterious death that involved another close friend of Michael who was found dead at the bottom of a staircase The investigation will keep fans guessing as to the guilt or innocence of those involved and as to what happened to Kathleen Peterson in reality.
11. Wormwood (2017)
Project MKUltra trials led to the “jumping” death of a top CIA scientist, but suspicions soon turned towards a coverup, as documented by legendary documentarian Errol Morris during his investigation.
While the son of the man whose death was ruled a suicide speaks about his quest to uncover the truth, actors like Peter Sarsgaard bring moments and characters from the case’s past to life, immersing viewers like never before in Wormwood.
10. The Jinx: The Life And Deaths Of Robert Durst (2015)
Robert Durst’s story is an example of how reality can be stranger than fiction.
There are six episodes of a documentary series called The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst that follow the life of the infamous serial killer. The series features hours of interview footage with Robert Alan Durst, who was notoriously uncooperative with journalists. Mr. Durst, who is a multi-millionaire, is wanted for the murders of three people in three different states. Robert Durst, the wealthy son of NYC real estate investor Seymour Durst, has always shown odd behavior, and it’s safe to say that he’s only gotten stranger over time.
Several key pieces of evidence that will be used in Durst’s upcoming murder trial are intercut into the Jinx miniseries. You’ll be baffled for hours by the eccentric murderer’s rambling interviews and startling revelations, and you’ll lock your doors extra tight as a result. The Jinx: The Life And Deaths Of Robert Durstexamines all of Robert Durst’s guises.
9. The Witness (2015)
A young woman was raped and killed in New York City in March 1964. Despite being one of the most well-known crimes in modern American history, the murder of Kitty Genovese — and the 38 witnesses who were present for the 30-minute attack but did nothing to help — continues to arouse strong emotions and vexing debates.
As narrated by her younger brother William Genovese, The Witness delves into a crime that has gripped the nation and puts a face to “the bystander effect,” revealing bombshells that The New York Times probably would have preferred to remain a mystery in the last few decades. If you believe you know the chilling details of one of America’s most famous homicides, think again.
8. Josef Fritzl: Story Of A Monster (2010)
The Life and Times of Josef Fritzl
exposes a crime that is both horrifying and perplexing — a sobering reminder that even the most heinous monsters can be found in the human race.. Watching the documentary provides viewers with an unvarnished look at the heinous man’s life and mind as he endured decades of sexual, physical, and mental abuse. Fritzl kidnapped his daughter Elisabeth at the age of 18 and imprisoned her in a dungeon he built beneath the family home for the next 24 years.
Elisabeth was sexually abused by her father and forced to give birth to seven children while living in a damp, windowless cement vault. Interviewing doctors and Fritzl’s relatives to tell the story of Elisabeth’s nightmare, Josef Fritzl: Story of a Monsterwill make you question human nature, how well you know your neighbors and what it truly means to be evil.
7. Child Of Rage (1990)
Child of Rageis an unfiltered look into the mind of six-year-old Beth, compiled from real footage of Dr. Ken Magid’s interviews with young children whose early trauma was so severe that they cannot form healthy bonds with other people. In an interview that is both gripping and terrifying, Beth opens up about her murderous impulses and admits openly to keeping a stash of knives in her room with the intention of stabbing her adoptive parents to death with one of them.
Because of this, it only serves to highlight Beth and her brother’s father’s abuse. For example, the six-year-old uses the word “boo-boo” in reference to the vicious attacks she commits on her younger brother. The short film concludes with updates on Beth’s journey and growth with the help of doctors, specialists and a home dedicated to caring for children with such extreme trauma. Even though the documentary is only a few minutes long, you’ll be thinking about what you learned from it for a long time.
6. Abducted In Plain Sight (2017)
Abducted in Plain Sight tells the story of Jan Broberg Felt, a 12-year-old girl who was kidnapped twice by her next-door neighbor when she was just 14 years old. The documentary features Felt and her family, including her mother, father, and siblings. Piece by piece, Robert Berchtold’s thriller Abducted in Plain Sight reveals how the Idaho teen ended up in his clutches. In front of Jan’s parents, Berchtold exploited and abused his family’s trust.
The film is chock-full of shocking revelations and dramatic turns, making the abductions themselves all the more horrifying. Jan’s parents added insult to injury by welcoming Berchtold back into their lives after her first kidnapping due to their gullibility and conceited self-preservation. It will make you question your neighbors and send your mind reeling when Netflix releases Abducted in Plain Sight in 2019.
5. Audrie & Daisy (2016)
Audrey and Daisy tells the story of two young girls, two rapes, two closed communities, and a tragic death that happened to one of the girls. They were raped on video and subjected to further abuse by vicious cyberbullies when they were 15 and 14 years old, respectively. Audrie Pott was raped, but unlike Daisy, she did not appear in the documentary to tell her story because she committed suicide soon after the attack.
The documentary, which was shot over the course of two years and features interviews with Daisy, her family, and two of the boys responsible for Audrie’s attack, documents the vicious assaults and their painful aftermath.
Our social media-obsessed culture’s condemnation of victims is vividly depicted in the documentary Audrie & Daisy, a riveting look at modern rape culture.
4. Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father (2008)
Greetings, Zachary. The documentary A Letter to a Son About His Father is unlike anything else you’ve seen before. When Andrew Bagby, a young physician, was murdered by his ex-lover, his best friend Kurt Kuenne, the director of the film, traveled across the country to collect interviews with Bagby’s friends and family as a sort of tribute. Bagby’s ex-girlfriend Shirley Turner was arrested and charged with his murder. Turner, a Canadian citizen, fled to St. John’s, Newfoundland, where he was arrested. Turner’s pregnancy with Bagby’s child, Zachary, added insult to injury.
It’s best to watch the documentary without prior knowledge, as the fight for Zachary — and for justice — takes dramatic turns and turns throughout the course of the film.
Greetings, Zachary. As the final, tragic twist will have you sobbing and screaming, A Letter to a Son About His Father is both moving and infuriating.
3. The Imposter (2012)
Is it possible that you don’t know your own family very well? Would you recognize your son if it had been three years since you last saw him? The Barclays, on the other hand, did not. During a basketball game with friends in 1994, Nicholas Barclay vanished without a trace. It took three years for “he” to be rediscovered, but there was something off about his whereabouts. Nicholas seemed disjointed to me. The young man’s appearance and demeanor had shifted dramatically since he vanished. The two of them don’t seem like the same people…
However, this isn’t the case. Frédéric Bourdin was 1997’s “Nicholas.” Frédéric Bourdin, a 23-year-old at the time, stole the boy’s identity, and The Imposter tells the story of how and why. Frédéric Bourdin’s arrogant interviews about outsmarting the press, the law, and most troublingly, the Barclays, are juxtaposed with emotional accounts from the bereaved Barclays. This documentary could easily be mistaken for a Hollywood thriller thanks to the M. Night Shyamalan-style twists and deceptively layered lives. For anyone interested in crime documentaries, The Imposteris a must-see.
2. Thought Crimes: The Case Of The Cannibal Cop (2015)
Preparation is key for watching this documentary with friends because you’ll have plenty to discuss once the credits start rolling. This documentary will take you down a slippery slope while simultaneously making you think. According to a new documentary from HBO, Thought Crimes: The Case of the Cannibal Cop, ex-cop Gilberto Valle III was accused of kidnapping due to evidence found on his computer, which revealed his plans to kidnap, torture, rape, and eat women. What’s the final word? Innocent.
DespiteValle’s conviction, the judge in the case threw out his decision. However, despite the fact that this is shocking, consider the following: Is Valle in fact a criminal? The film explores the never-before-examined legal question of when reporting on criminal activity, no matter how gruesome, becomes criminal intent. There is no doubt that Valle’s writing is repulsive. Is it fair to punish someone for thinking about committing a crime before they do it?
1. Killer Legends (2014)
Director Joshua Zerman and researcher Rachel Mills look into the origins of the urban legends we tell around campfires and share at sleepovers in this documentary. As a result of their investigation, the pair visits Texas, Missouri, and Illinois to find out if The Hookman, The Candyman, The Babysitter, the Man Above and the Killer Clown are real or just urban legends.
In the same vein as Cropsey (another must-see urban legend exposé), Killer Legends is engrossing, fascinating, and downright creepy. The truth is stranger — and scarier — than fiction, so don’t bother reading Killer Legends if you want to keep telling yourself these monsters only exist in scary stories.