These shows either have a quirky nature like Lucifer or have a plot that is similar enough to the series to instantly turn a casual viewer into a fan.
When a dark character is pitted against equally evil opponents, there’s a certain allure to the situation. The success of Lucifer can be attributed to the mischievous nature of the show’s titular protagonist as well as the show’s unique blend of comedy and police procedural elements. The series may not be identical, but there are some that are extremely close.
Interested viewers are always on the lookout for new shows to watch. Fortunately, there are still plenty of options for fans to choose from. Depending on your tastes, these shows will either remind you of Lucifer in terms of quirkiness or have similarities to the series’ premise that will win you over as a fan right away.
Gabriela Silva posted this update on September 30th, 2020:
Lucifer fans can only hope for a seventh season, but there are plenty of other shows to keep them entertained until then. As the King of Hell navigates love, crime, and his celestial family, audiences were smitten.
Since 2016, the show has provided viewers with a diverse range of themes to keep them engaged. If you want to experience the same thrill that Lucifer does, here are some suggestions for new binge-worthy content.
16. The Vampire Diaries (2009-2017)
Even years after it ended, The Vampire Diaries continues to be a popular teen drama on the CW. Also, it’s a huge hit with Lucifer devotees because of the gripping supernatural plot. According to Wikipedia, the show is based on L.J. Smith’s series of books of the same name.
A new yet familiar visitor arrives in the small town of Mystic Falls. Elena Gilbert (Nina Dobrev) is a human who falls in love with a vampire and becomes embroiled in the town’s supernatural history, as well as a steamy love triangle, on the show.
15. iZombie (2015-2019)
Show on the CW
In iZombie, the undead and a crime procedural get a new twist. After going to a boat party, a medical resident discovers that he has more than just a hangover when he gets home. After a zombie rage, she awakens among the living dead. Now she has to figure out how to get by in a new environment while keeping her secret a secret from everyone.
She’s now a medical examiner for the Seattle Police Department, where she uses her special skills to help solve crimes. As a result of eating the victims’ brains, she is able to go back in time and relive their past selves.
14. Moonlight (2007-2008)
Fans of Moonlight, a show from the early 2000s, are perplexed as to why it was cancelled. Unfortunately, there was only one season of the show, which is a real shame. Despite this, it’s still well worth watching because it successfully blends vampires and crime drama.
The paranormal romance series is centered on a private investigator with a sinister past. A vampire possessed him for fifty-five years prior to this. He’s now assisting law enforcement in the investigation of crimes and battling other bloodsuckers in Los Angeles. Don’t worry, there will be some romance between vampires and humans in the show.
13. Fringe (2008-2013)
This show is perfect for Lucifer fans who want a crime procedural with a dash of the supernatural, such as J.J. Abrams’ Fringe from the mid-2000s. Homeland Security has a specialized unit known as the Fringe Division.
Fringe science is a new method of investigation used by the team. As they look into strange crimes, they deviate from standard police procedure. The mysteries of a parallel universe are at the heart of these cases.
12. American Gods (2017)
There aren’t celestial beings in American Gods like those in Lucifer’s world. This book, on the other hand, focuses on the idea of Gods. After learning he had lost his wife, Shadow Moon (Ricky Whittle) is released from prison.
Then he meets Mr. Wednesday (Ian McShane), who hires him as a bodyguard and driver for his security firm Moon is sucked into a fantasy world populated by wizards and demigods. With each passing day, the New Gods’ power grows stronger, posing a growing threat to the Old Gods’.
11. Evil (2019)
A 2019 show called Evil may go unnoticed due to its release date. A season of the show was already completed before Netflix decided to continue streaming it.
Fans of Lucifer will enjoy the supernatural and crime elements in this new show. A forensic scientist and a Catholic seminarian team up in this story, giving it a religious undertone. They look into paranormal events with the help of a technology contractor.
10. Sleepy Hollow (2013-2017)
After a confrontation with a Horseman, a soldier serving as a double agent for George Washington is sent to sleep for a long time. The Headless Horseman mystery and other crimes are solved when he reawakens more than two centuries later and works with an FBI agent.
Sleepy Hollow is a procedural/drama/fantasy hybrid that is based on a novel by Washington Irving. As a result of his attitude and his “fish out of water” demeanor,”Ichabod Crane” is easily the most engaging character in the story. Not to mention his relationship with his fellow FBI agent.
9. Good Omens (2019)
A pair of angels and demons who have known each other their entire lives despite their polar opposite personalities join forces to stop the Antichrist from appearing. With the end of the world looming, the two must pool their resources to ensure the survival of the human race.
Good Omens stands out among David Tennant’s stellar performances over the years. Aziraphale, played by Michael Sheen, contrasts Tennant’s demonic Crowley with Tennant’s demonic Crowley, played by Michael Tennant.
8. Constantine (2014-2015)
In search of new foes to battle, a supernatural hunter with mastery of the occult travels across the country. John Constantine is up against a lot of obstacles when it comes to dealing with these other-worldly beings because of his anti-hero mentality and questionable past.
Because of the striking resemblance between Constantine and Lucifer, the two eventually met in Crisis on Infinite Earths, where it was revealed they’re old friends. While Constantine may feature occult creatures, the snarky protagonist makes it a fun film to watch.
7. Preacher (2016-2019)
A preacher with a penchant for vices learns that he possesses a superpower that allows him to direct the behavior of others. Now that he’s equipped with this power and facing a crisis of faith, he embarks on a journey to meet God face to face.
Fans of Lucifer will recognize Preacher’s central character’s conflict with his father, and these viewers will have no trouble connecting with him. This enlightenment journey is made all the more exciting by the protagonist’s unconventional methods and his equally crazy sidekicks.
6. Forever (2014-2015)
Henry Morgan is a medical examiner who appears to be just like everyone else, but his secret of eternal life is anything but ordinary. Over the course of two centuries, he has been solving crimes to try and put an end to his existence.
The mystery surrounding the main character’s immortality makes Forever stand out among other crime dramas on television. Even though the show only has one season, the thematic elements make it memorable. The fact that Henry is so out of touch with modern life adds a lot of levity.
5. Pushing Daisies (2007-2009)
When Ned, a pie-maker, touches someone, they come back to life. He makes use of this power to help a private investigator solve murders that are still unsolved. Things get out of hand when Ned brings back his childhood sweetheart, too.
While the show does have a fantasy feel to it, the detective aspects are well worth watching. Rather than anything else, Pushing Daisies’ stunning visuals and cinematography will mesmerize viewers. Lucifer, on the other hand, makes excellent use of the devilish theme, and this is oddly similar while also providing a stark contrast due to its vibrant colors.
4. Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina (2018)
Sabrina, a teenage witch in Greendale, Indiana, begins her dark education while also attempting to maintain a normal lifestyle. Evil forces, on the other hand, regularly confront Sabrina, threatening her with terrible consequences if she fails.
Dark fantasy fans will enjoy this show even though it’s not a procedural like Lucifer. This Sabrina has a darker tone than the original sitcom, and it delves deeper into the mythology of witchcraft and demons.
3. Castle (2009-2016)
Thriller author Rick Castle uses his clout to join forces with a homicide detective. Despite their friendly rivalry, the two form a formidable team when it comes to catching and prosecuting high-profile criminals. The two develop feelings for one another over time.
Although the dynamic between the leads is very similar to Chloe and Lucifer, it doesn’t carry a fantasy theme like Lucifer. There are few series as entertaining as Castle and Beckett are when they are constantly at each other’s throats and their many intriguing cases fall into place.
2. Grimm (2011-2017)
Homicide detective Nick Burkhardt also happens to be a skilled supernatural hunter. Due to his heritage as a “Grimm,” he faces many foes with the help of those he trusts.
It’s well-known for both its mystery and the way the characters are presented. While there isn’t much in the way of comedy like in Lucifer, the occult and horror themes are too compelling to ignore. Grimm’s supernatural cases are also well written and important to the story’s overall arc, as can be seen.
1. Supernatural (2005-2020)
The Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean, grew up in a hunting community. They discover they are destined to avert the apocalypse as they travel the country fighting the supernatural while also helping others. At some point in their journey, they’ll have to face the devil as well as God.
There’s a lot of discussion about whether or not Lucifer Morningstar from this show is superior. Overall, Supernatural is a dark fantasy show with plenty of lore. The brothers are well-rounded characters who team up to take on demons, angels, and other supernatural foes in the fifteen seasons of the show.
Saim Cheeda is a film, television, video game, and book critic. Since 2017, he’s written 500+ articles for Valnet’s The Gamer, The Things, Game Rant, Comic Book Resources, and Screen Rant, among other publications. Saim is also a lifestyle blogger and co-founder of the website 3 States Apart in addition to freelance writing.